Online Orders Menu

****PLEASE READ**** Orders must be submitted by end of day the Wednesday before pickup. All items are baked fresh to order on the day of pickup. Have a craving for something specific or inquiries on ingredients, bulk orders, and catering? Send us an email to bennysbakeshopgf@gmail.com

Muffins

Blueberry Muffin

Single

$4.25

4-count

$16

Chocolate Chip Muffin

Single

$4.25

4-count

$16

Cranberry Orange Pecan Muffin

Single

$4.25

4-count

$16

Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Single

$3.25

6-count

$16.50

12-count

$27.50

Vegan

Vanilla Sugar Cookie

Single

$3.25

6-count

$16.50

12-count

$27.50

Snickerdoodle Cookie

Single

$3.25

6-count

$16.50

12-count

$27.50

Pumpkin Snickerdoodle Cookie

A twist on a traditional snickerdoodle with the addition of pumpkin puree for a familiar fall favorite flavor.

Single

$3.25

6-count

$16.50

12-count

$27.50

Peanut Butter Cookies

Made with Reece's Peanut Butter and topped with chopped peanuts and peanut butter cups

Single

$3.25

6-count

$16.50

12-count

$27.50

Oatmeal Cookie

A bit of a twist on an original dessert. Combining flavors of oats, amaranth, corn masa flour, and more, these oatmeal cookies are sure to delight.

Single

$3.25

6-count

$16.50

12-count

$27.50

Mix-Ins

Chocolate chips

$0.25

Chopped pecans

$0.25

Raisins

$0.25

Seasonal Sweet Treats

Poinsettia Cupcakes (6 count)

cupcakes with poinsettia motifs piped on top

$24

Cupcake Flavors

Yellow Cake

Chocolate Cake

Savory Treats

Cheddar Coins

Cheddar cheese with a hint of cayenne, these cheese crackers are staff favorite

Honey Oat Sandwich Bread

As all ingredients are fresh with no preservatives, bread is freshest within the first two to three days.

Half-Loaf

Full Loaf

$12

Bread - Pre-Slicing

Sliced (normal 1/2 inch)

Sliced (thin)

Sliced (thick)